ToonForum - Newcastle United Forum

Didn't realise that if you changs the poll it wipes the results

Should've put an "other " option aswell

Richard Dunne for me, has looked absolutely hopeless for about five seasons now but seems to get worse with each campaign. He's so slow and awkward, I honestly think he's worse than Williamson.

You know.. Later today if we're drawing he'll bring on Sammy to try and win the game. Hahahahaha.

Star-Lord Mehdi wrote:You know.. Later today if we're drawing he'll bring on Sammy to try and win the game. Hahahahaha.

...
Not funny at all. Him blasting balls from 35 yards boils my piss.

Aldridge Prior wrote:Richard Dunne for me, has looked absolutely hopeless for about five seasons now but seems to get worse with each campaign. He's so slow and awkward, I honestly think he's worse than Williamson.

He's a competent footballer though. He looks like he knows how to kick a ball and if he was playing 5-a-side with you and your mates he'd be the best player by a mile. Williamson on the other hand would be terrible at 5-a-side too.

biggeordiedave wrote:

Aldridge Prior wrote:Richard Dunne for me, has looked absolutely hopeless for about five seasons now but seems to get worse with each campaign. He's so slow and awkward, I honestly think he's worse than Williamson.

He's a competent footballer though. He looks like he knows how to kick a ball and if he was playing 5-a-side with you and your mates he'd be the best player by a mile. Williamson on the other hand would be terrible at 5-a-side too.

biggeordiedave is correct, Dunne isn't brilliant, but he holds a line, same with Clint Hill, only so much they can do.

Name one defender in a worse position than us right now, you can't. I'd take Hill and Dunne in a heartbeat.

Imagine how different it would have been if Steven Taylor had stayed fit.

Toondes wrote:Imagine how different it would have been if Steven Taylor had stayed fit.

Yeah, we wouldn't be fighting off relegation on the final day.

Anyone who doesn't vote Williamson needs their head examined.

Williamson is terminally limited but does what he can. Ryan Taylor was past it as a Premier League player two seasons ago and isn't a central midfielder, yet is inexplicably starting over at least two better centre mids week in week out and forcing Colback to play as both centre mids at once.

Add to that the fact that the one thing he is on for is set pieces, and they've been s****.

How has Gouffran got no votes?! (until I just voted, ha) He's actually done NOTHING all season!

Matthieu wrote:

Toondes wrote:Imagine how different it would have been if Steven Taylor had stayed fit.

Yeah, we wouldn't be fighting off relegation on the final day.

We'd be comfortably safe, even with Carver as manager. Was it Southampton where Williamson was at fault for all 4 goals we conceded? <grim>

505 wrote:How has Gouffran got no votes?! (until I just voted, ha) He's actually done NOTHING all season!

Doing nothing is decidedly better than being actively destructive for the team, which I would say Williamson, Coloccinni and Ryan Taylor have been.

505 wrote:How has Gouffran got no votes?! (until I just voted, ha) He's actually done NOTHING all season!

I voted for him. I can't remember a single decent game hes had

I voted Sammy.

Mike Williamson by a f***ing country mile. The WORST defender in the Prem. How he continues to start baffles me. Useless cronut! Wouldn't surprise me if he causes the error that leads to a goal that would probably relegate us today.